ECA report: “The EU chemicals legislation is not well adapted to PFAS”; no EU-wide ban expected soon

News Tank Transitions - Paris - News #461076 - Published on -
- +
©  Adobe Stock
©  Adobe Stock

“The EU chemicals legislation has not kept pace with the scale of the problem regarding PFAS and is not well adapted. [...] Moreover, when PFAS is restricted, it often leads to a regrettable substitution,” said Joëlle Elvinger, member of the European Court of Auditors (ECA), when presenting the ECA’s latest report on these ‘forever chemicals’, published on 18/11/2026.

The objective of this audit was to assess whether the EU had been effective in protecting human health from the harmful effects of PFAS.

“The EU was among the first to restrict PFAS, as early as 2006, but the majority of such chemicals are not registered under REACH, the EU’s system for regulating chemicals,” the report points out.

In practice, the EU’s ‘no data, no market’ principle barely applies to PFAS. Forever chemicals can remain on the market even when there is not enough information about their risks, the auditors warn.

“One reason for this is that full testing data is only required for chemical substances that have an annual volume manufactured or imported of more than 1,000 tons,” Joëlle Elvinger added.

When the EU does actually regulate PFAS, the process is slow and can miss its target. Restriction procedures take around five years on average, giving manufacturers time to replace a banned substance with a similar chemical that may be just as harmful - a practice known as ‘regrettable substitution’, the ECA's report underlines.

The auditors also underline another weakness: “The system relies heavily on companies checking their own compliance, while one in three member states still fails to carry out any checks to enforce PFAS restrictions”.

In response to PFAS contamination risks, a third of EU countries have already adopted additional national limits for drinking water, and at least two have already introduced tighter restrictions for consumer products than those that currently apply at EU level.

"Five countries also proposed an EU-wide restriction on all PFAS in 2021, but the scale and complexity of the restriction have held up progress. Meanwhile, no new PFAS restrictions have since been launched at EU level, despite growing evidence of health and environmental risks. Until broader rules eventually take effect, most forever chemicals can still be sold and used in the EU - and continue to accumulate in our bodies and the environment," the report concludes.


“Current limits for food and water are not enough to protect human health”

The analysis from the ECA shows that “current limits for food and water are not enough to protect human health,” reports Joëlle Elvinger.

Partly because those limits are only established if there is scientific evidence that a contaminant poses a risk to human health, and such scientific evidence is not available for many food products.

The ECA member also points out that “even when the Commission has access to the data — from the European Food Safety Authority, for example —, it has not been used to update existing limits”.

Regarding drinking water, limits are set out in the 2020 Drinking Water Directive, and according to the ECA, these are “generally respected”, even though they are based on evidence from 2017.

Universal PFAS restriction still has to go “through the process of decision-making”

About a future universal PFAS restriction, submitted by the Netherlands, Germany, Denmark, Norway and Sweden, Joëlle Elvinger says that the outcome and the timing are uncertain.

Considering the expected timetable detailed in the report, José Parenta adds: “We are close to the end of the second phase, which is the consultations and opinion development. But we will still have to go through the process of decision-making, which is the responsibility of the Commission and the legislators.”

According to the report, "an EU-wide restriction covering all PFAS is unlikely to be introduced anytime soon."

The phases and timeline of recent PFAS (“forever chemicals”) restrictions - ©  ECA

“One third of 27 EU member states did not carry out any targeted PFAS controls”

Moreover, the report found that “many member states do not check compliance with PFAS restrictions. One third of the 27 EU member states replied to our survey that they did not carry out any targeted PFAS controls to check compliance with EU chemicals legislation,” continues Joelle Elvinger.

While member states have to report their checks on PFAS in food, “we found that for the 2020-2024 period, five member states did not submit any data. And for the member states that did, the number of checks varies significantly”.

According to her, these checks are also “not done equally by the countries: some are reporting only five PFAS while others are reporting 90,000 PFAS in food”.

The TFA's case

José Parenta, lead author of the report, underlines that “there is a raised awareness regarding TFA, but sometimes the problem is that it takes a significant amount of time to collect information about the products.

The problem, according to him, is the length of the existing process of the restriction in the EU, which “needs to be faster”.

ECA's recommendations

  • Improve the regulatory procedures to take action against harmful PFAS. Addressed to the Commission, working with the European Chemicals Agency.
    • Speed up the decision on the proposed universal PFAS restriction, without prejudging the outcome. Target: 2027.
    • Streamline chemicals legislation procedures so action against harmful PFAS takes less time. Target: 2029.
  • Put in place checks to verify compliance with chemicals legislation. Addressed to the Commission.
    • Work with Member States to set up an effective system of controls on PFAS. Target: 2028.
  • Revise the limits for PFAS in food and support Member States’ monitoring and control. Addressed to the Commission.
    • Revise the limits for PFAS in food in line with the latest scientific and monitoring data.
    • Give Member States guidance on monitoring and controlling PFAS in food, and on sending the data to the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Target: 2028.

  • Assess the adequacy of the current PFAS limits in drinking water (target: 2028). Addressed to the Commission together with the Member States.
    • Assess whether the current limits are adequate, taking into account the EFSA opinion and recent scientific data.
    • Propose new limits where warranted.

Discover News Tank Transitions

Request your discovery subscription and enjoy 30 days of free access.

Create my account Our subscription plans

©  Adobe Stock
©  Adobe Stock